Peer Review Policy

1. Peer Review Model and Process
Review Model: JHSS employs double-blind peer review. Author identities are concealed from reviewers, and reviewer identities remain confidential from authors and from co-reviewers.
Each manuscript is assigned by the Editor-in-Chief to 2–3 anonymous reviewers with relevant subject-matter expertise.
Reviewers are expected to submit their reports within 3 weeks of invitation. Extensions beyond this period must be requested from the Editorial Office at least 2 business days in advance.
Within 3 business days of receiving all reviewer reports, the editorial office renders a decision based on the reviewers' comments and the academic editor's assessment: (1) accept; (2) minor revisions; (3) major revisions; (4) reject.
Authors of revised manuscripts must return their revised submission and a point-by-point response letter within 4 weeks. Major-revision manuscripts are returned to the original reviewers for re-evaluation.
Fast-track commitment: The target time from submission to first decision is 5–7 weeks; from acceptance to online publication is 2–3 weeks.
2. Reviewer Obligations
Reviewers who identify a conflict of interest, cannot complete the review within the stipulated period, or consider the manuscript outside their area of expertise must notify the editorial office and decline the invitation within 3 business days. Review reports must be objective, specific, and constructive, and must not contain personal or ad hominem criticism.

 

---
Document No.: JHSS-POL-002
Version: v1.0
Effective Date: [2026-01-01]